Should I Hire a Lead Gen Agency? Check Your Offer First

More leads only help if your offer can turn them into customers. Eight questions to answer before you pay anyone to fill your calendar.

No. 26

Photo: Josefina Diaz Abal on Dupe

The short answer

Only once your offer converts the leads you already get. If calls end in "let me think about it", more calls just show you the same problem faster. Check the outcome you promise, your proof, your risk reversal and your price first. Then buy more leads.

More calls won't fix a weak offer

Here's a pattern you might know. You get a few calls a month. People are friendly. They say it sounds great. Then they go quiet.

The obvious fix is more calls, so you look at lead gen agencies. But if the offer isn't landing, more calls just show you the same problem faster, and you pay for each one.

Fix what happens on the call before you pay to have more of them.

Eight questions to answer first

These are worth an honest hour before you spend anything.

  1. What expensive problem do you solve? Name it in the buyer's words, and say what changes for them after it's gone. If the answer is a list of deliverables, keep going.
  2. What are your competitors promising? Read three of their websites. Find the promise none of them make, or make well.
  3. What proof do you have? Results, examples, a sample of the work. If you have no case studies yet, show the work itself.
  4. Can you deliver it without burning out? An offer you can only fulfil by working weekends won't last ten clients.
  5. How does it work? Buyers trust a method they can picture. Give yours a shape: steps, an order, a timeline.
  6. What makes it less risky to say yes? Clear expectations, milestones, a guarantee on the work you control. Remove the reasons to wait.
  7. Is the price set by the outcome? Pricing against the cheapest competitor tells buyers what you think you're worth.
  8. Why won't people buy? Write down every objection you've heard. Count how many your offer already answers.

The value equation, briefly

Alex Hormozi's value equation is a useful check. An offer feels more valuable when the outcome is bigger and the buyer believes it will happen. It feels less valuable the longer it takes and the more effort it costs them.

Most offers can be improved without changing the work. Show proof, so the result feels more likely. Show the first win early, so it feels faster. Take the busywork off the client, so it costs them less effort.

When it's time to buy leads

You're ready when the calls you already get turn into customers at a rate you're happy with, and you can say why. At that point, more leads really are the bottleneck, and spending on them makes sense.

Want to test your offer on real buyers first? Start with 50 free leads who match your buyer, and see what happens when you reach out.

Written by the Breakout Labs team. We try everything we write about on our own pipeline first. Think we got something wrong? Tell us at team@breakout-labs.co. A person reads every email.

Common questions

How do I know if my offer is the problem, not my lead flow?

Look at what happens on the calls you already have. If people show up, nod along and then go quiet, the offer is the problem. If you simply have no calls, lead flow is.

What is the value equation?

Alex Hormozi's way of judging an offer: value goes up with the size of the outcome and how likely the buyer thinks it is, and goes down with how long it takes and how much effort it costs them.